Local business? Support local news on VanAlstyne.city

Back to Texas

Cornyn holds up Trump's late pick for a Dallas federal judgeship, saying the nominee is not from Texas

Sen. John Cornyn says he will not return the blue slip for Elliot Gaiser, which stalls the nomination. Sen. Ted Cruz backs Gaiser and warns a new pick may not clear vetting before Democrats take the Senate.

Jubal Pennington· AI-assisted, edited by Jake Team

November 18, 20263 min read

Federal Judiciary - illustration, Jake Team LLC

Sen. John Cornyn is refusing to sign off on President Donald Trump's nominee for a federal judgeship in North Texas, leaving the nomination stuck with only weeks left before a Democratic majority is seated in the U.S. Senate, The Texas Tribune reported Wednesday.

Trump nominated Elliot Gaiser, who heads the Justice Department's Office of Legal Counsel, to a district judge seat in the Northern District of Texas. The court sits in Dallas and covers 100 counties.

In an interview with The Associated Press, Cornyn said he has not returned his "blue slip" for Gaiser and does not intend to. Under that Senate custom, home-state senators signal whether the Judiciary Committee may move ahead on a judicial nominee from their state, and the Tribune reported that the nomination cannot advance without it.

"He's not from Texas," Cornyn said in the AP interview. "He hasn't been vetted. And this is a lifetime job, and there's better qualified people to hold that job."

The two senators split

Gaiser is a former Ohio solicitor general who worked on Trump's 2020 campaign, and most of his legal career has been in Ohio and Washington, according to the Tribune. He is a former law clerk to Justice Samuel Alito of the U.S. Supreme Court. Both Texas senators voted to confirm him to his Justice Department post last year.

Sen. Ted Cruz supports the nomination and has met with Gaiser. In a statement, Cruz called him "exceptionally well qualified" and argued that time is the problem: a brand-new nominee would need an FBI background check, while Gaiser, as a sitting senior Justice Department official, already has one.

"Gaiser is also the only nominee who could actually be confirmed by the end of the year," Cruz said.

Cornyn said the White House skipped the usual process in which he and Cruz screen candidates through a bipartisan evaluation committee, even after the two sent over several qualified names.

His own recommendation is Steve Fahey, a Dallas partner at Kirkland & Ellis who once ran criminal prosecutions for the federal prosecutor's office in that district, and Cornyn told the AP the White House has asked for information about him. Cornyn also said he felt bad for Gaiser, who he said had been used "as a pawn."

The timeline

The seat opened when Judge Jane Boyle, appointed by President George W. Bush, took senior status Oct. 1. The district has two vacancies, and seven of its 10 sitting district judges were appointed by Trump, the Tribune reported.

Gaiser's committee questionnaire shows Cruz's staff reached out to him on Nov. 4, one day after Election Day. Trump announced the pick Nov. 9, and the formal nomination reached the Senate Nov. 16.

The Judiciary Committee held a hearing Wednesday on seven other judicial nominees, including Texas Supreme Court Justice James Sullivan, nominated for a federal trial seat in West Texas after he lost his state court race this month. Gaiser was not on the list.

When the new Senate is seated in January, Sen.-elect James Talarico will get his own blue slip, so future Texas nominees from either party would need approval from both Cruz and Talarico.

Sources

The Texas Tribune

Share

Jubal Pennington· AI-assisted, edited by Jake Team

Jubal Pennington writes about community life, schools, public safety, and neighborhood happenings around Van Alstyne.

Related Stories

More in Sport

Sport

Gafford and Martin Filled the Jobs Left Around Dallas’s Stars

Daniel Gafford and Caleb Martin did not need big scoring nights to shape Dallas’ 116-94 victory over Golden State. Their timely baskets, rebounding and defensive contributions gave the Mavericks enough connective play for Cooper Flagg and P.J. Washington to turn a comfortable lead into a rout.

Cody FerrisNovember 19, 20263 min read
Sport

Joakim Soria’s Texas Value Reaches Beyond His 17 Saves

Joakim Soria’s first Hall of Fame ballot appearance brings his Texas years into focus: a modest 2013, an efficient 2014 and a career whose value rests on preventing runs across changing roles.

Cody FerrisNovember 17, 20264 min read